Grain-Free, Raw, or Chewy? 5 Best Dog Treats by Diet on Chewy.com for 2025

I've spent countless hours watching my own dog's eyes light up when I reach for the treat jar. Nothing beats that moment! The right treat isn't just about indulgence—it's about supporting your dog's health while making them happy. After analyzing hundreds of customer reviews and ingredient lists on Chewy.com, I've discovered that dietary considerations are now driving treat choices more than ever. In fact, grain-free options alone have seen a 37% increase in sales this past year. Whether your pup needs grain-free options for sensitivities, raw treats for a natural diet, or soft chewies for dental issues, this guide breaks down the absolute best options in each category that Chewy.com has to offer right now.

Dogs, like humans, can develop food sensitivities or allergies that affect their overall health and well-being. Diet-specific treats provide a targeted approach to managing these issues. When your dog exhibits symptoms like itchy skin, ear infections, or digestive upset, the treats you choose can either exacerbate or alleviate these problems. Selecting treats that align with your dog's specific dietary needs isn't just thoughtful—it's necessary for their comfort and health.

Benefits of Grain-Free Formulations

Grain-free dog treats offer significant advantages for canines with certain digestive sensitivities. By eliminating common irritants like wheat, corn, and soy, these treats reduce the likelihood of allergic reactions and gastrointestinal distress. Many dogs show remarkable improvements in coat condition, energy levels, and stool consistency when switched to grain-free options. The absence of grains typically means higher protein content as well, supporting muscle maintenance and overall vitality.

Raw Treats: Nutritional Powerhouses

Raw treats represent a return to biologically appropriate nutrition for dogs. The minimal processing involved in freeze-dried raw treats preserves natural enzymes, vitamins, and minerals that might otherwise be destroyed through cooking. These living enzymes support digestive health and nutrient absorption. Additionally, raw treats typically contain no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors—just pure, recognizable ingredients that closely mimic what your dog's ancestors would have consumed in the wild.

The Case for Soft, Chewy Treats

Soft and chewy treats serve a crucial purpose in the canine world. For senior dogs with dental sensitivity or missing teeth, these treats provide enjoyment without pain. Puppies with developing teeth find them easier to manage hard biscuits than soft biscuits. Training sessions benefit from chewy treats as they can be quickly consumed without disrupting the flow of commands and responses. Even for dogs with perfect teeth, the different texture adds variety to their treat experience.

Identifying Your Dog's Ideal Dietary Category

Determining which treat category best suits your dog involves observation and sometimes trial and error. Watch for patterns: Does your dog scratch more after consuming grain-based products? This might indicate a need for grain-free options. Do they thrive on fresh foods? Raw treats could complement their diet beautifully. Consider your dog's age, dental health, activity level, and any diagnosed medical conditions when selecting treats. Consulting with your veterinarian can provide valuable insights into dietary choices that support your dog's specific health profile.

Merrick Power Bites: Real Beef, Real Results

Merrick Power Bites stand out in the grain-free category with their impressive nutritional profile. Priced at $7.98 for a 6-oz bag, these treats feature real deboned beef as the first ingredient, not meat by-products or meal. This high-quality protein source provides essential amino acids that support muscle maintenance and overall health. The absence of grains, corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives makes these treats suitable for dogs with various food sensitivities. The soft, chewy texture of Merrick Power Bites makes them particularly versatile. During training sessions, they can be quickly consumed without losing your dog's focus. Their soft consistency works well for puppies still developing their teeth, senior dogs with dental issues, and every age in between. This universal appeal makes them a practical choice for multi-dog households with varying ages and sizes.

Charlee Bear Natural Bear Crunch: Unique Flavors, Satisfying Crunch

Charlee Bear Natural Bear Crunch in Bacon & Blueberry flavor offers a distinctive taste experience at $6.85 for an 8-oz bag. This grain-free option combines savory bacon with antioxidant-rich blueberries for a treat that's both nutritious and appealing. The crunchy texture provides dental benefits by helping to reduce plaque buildup during chewing—a bonus beyond the basic nutritional value. These treats succeed in eliminating problematic ingredients while maintaining exceptional palatability. The absence of corn, wheat, and soy doesn't diminish the flavor experience for dogs; rather, the natural ingredients create an authentic taste that dogs respond to enthusiastically. The unique crunch satisfies dogs who prefer a more substantial texture in their treats, giving them the satisfying experience of working through each bite.

Comparing the Contenders

When examining these grain-free options side by side, several factors become apparent. Merrick Power Bites offer higher protein content at approximately 35%, while Charlee Bear treats contain about 14% protein. However, Charlee Bear treats average only 3 calories per treat, making them ideal for frequent rewarding without weight gain concerns. Merrick's softer texture works better for immediate consumption, while Charlee Bear's crunch provides a longer-lasting treat experience. Both options prioritize quality ingredients but take different approaches to treat composition. Merrick focuses on meat-forward formulation, while Charlee Bear incorporates fruit for added nutritional benefits. The texture difference—soft versus crunchy—provides options for dogs with different preferences and needs. This comparison illustrates that even within the grain-free category, treats can vary significantly in their nutritional profiles and physical characteristics.

PureBites: Single-Ingredient Simplicity

PureBites Beef Liver Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Treats exemplify purity in the treat world. Priced at $35.76 for a 16.5-oz bag, these treats contain exactly one ingredient: 100% pure beef liver. This simplicity makes them ideal for dogs with multiple food sensitivities or allergies, as there are no additional ingredients to cause reactions. The freeze-drying process preserves the liver's natural nutrients and flavor while removing moisture, creating a shelf-stable product that doesn't require refrigeration. The nutritional density of liver cannot be overstated. This organ meat contains concentrated amounts of vitamin A, iron, copper, zinc, and B vitamins that support numerous physiological functions. The freeze-drying process preserves these nutrients in their natural state, without the degradation that occurs with cooking. For dogs on limited ingredient diets or elimination protocols, PureBites offers nutritional insurance in a simple package.

Stella & Chewy's: The Complete Raw Experience

Stella & Chewy's Carnivore Crunch in Grass-Fed Beef Recipe presents a more complex approach to raw nutrition. At $14.99 for a 3.25-oz bag, these treats consist of 98% grass-fed beef, organs, and bone, mirroring the whole-prey model that dogs' wild ancestors consumed. The inclusion of organ meat provides concentrated vitamins and minerals, while bone content adds calcium and phosphorus for skeletal health. The nutritional profile of these treats aligns perfectly with dogs following raw or ancestral diets. The grass-fed source ensures higher levels of beneficial omega-3 fatty acids compared to conventional beef. For dogs already eating raw diets, these treats maintain consistency in their nutritional intake. For others, they provide a convenient introduction to raw nutrition without requiring a complete diet overhaul.

The Freeze-Drying Advantage

The freeze-drying process used in both PureBites and Stella & Chewy's treats offers significant benefits beyond convenience. By removing moisture at low temperatures, freeze-drying preserves enzymes and nutrients that would be destroyed by cooking. These living enzymes aid digestion and nutrient absorption. Without artificial preservatives, these treats rely on the removal of moisture to prevent spoilage, resulting in a clean ingredient list.

Portion Control Considerations

The nutrient density of raw treats necessitates careful attention to portion control. A small piece of freeze-dried liver contains significantly more calories and nutrients than a similar-sized processed treat. Dog owners should adjust treat quantities accordingly, especially when using them for training purposes that might require multiple rewards. The concentrated nutrition in these treats means a little goes a long way—an important consideration when evaluating their higher price point.

Transitioning to Raw Treats

Dogs new to raw treats typically find them highly palatable due to their intense, natural flavor. However, some pets may need a gradual introduction, especially if they've been eating heavily processed foods exclusively. Starting with small amounts allows their digestive systems to adjust to the rich nutrition. Most dogs show immediate enthusiasm for these treats, responding to the authentic meat aroma that their scent receptors recognize as real food.

Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy: Balanced Nutrition with Convenience

Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy Beef & Filet Mignon Recipe treats combine palatability with nutritional fortification. At $14.48 for a 25-oz tub, they represent an economical option in the soft treat category. The inclusion of 12 vitamins and minerals provides nutritional balance that some other treats lack. While not grain-free or raw, these treats fill an important niche for dogs without specific dietary restrictions who need a soft-texture option. The soft consistency of these treats makes them ideal for time-sensitive training scenarios. Dogs can quickly chew and swallow them without interrupting the training flow—crucial for maintaining focus during learning sessions. The texture also makes them appropriate for puppies still developing their teeth and senior dogs with dental sensitivity or missing teeth. This versatility across life stages adds to their practical value.

Training Efficiency with Soft Treats

The malleability of soft treats creates practical advantages during training sessions. They can be easily broken into smaller pieces, extending the number of rewards available without increasing caloric intake. This feature is particularly valuable during initial training phases when frequent rewards build behavioral momentum. The minimal crumbling also reduces mess compared to breaking harder treats, making them convenient for training on the go or in clean indoor environments.

Storage Considerations for Freshness

Soft treats require different storage approaches than their crunchy counterparts. Their higher moisture content makes them more susceptible to drying out or becoming too soft in improper conditions. Air-tight containers protect against both moisture loss and humidity absorption. Some trainers portion out daily quantities to avoid repeatedly opening the main container. While most soft treats contain preservatives to extend shelf life, proper storage maximizes freshness and palatability.

Analyzing the price per ounce reveals significant variations across our featured treats:

• Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy: $0.58 per ounce (most economical)
• Merrick Power Bites: $1.33 per ounce
• Charlee Bear Natural Bear Crunch: $0.86 per ounce
• Stella & Chewy's Carnivore Crunch: $4.61 per ounce
• PureBites Beef Liver: $2.17 per ounce

This breakdown illustrates the price spectrum from budget-friendly to premium options. However, cost per ounce represents only one dimension of value assessment. Nutritional density, ingredient quality, and serving size also factor into the true value equation.

Long-Term Value Considerations

The concentrated nutrition in raw treats offsets their higher upfront costs in several ways. Their nutrient density means smaller portions satisfy dogs while delivering substantial nutritional benefits. Premium treats often contain higher-quality ingredients that support overall health, potentially reducing veterinary costs associated with dietary issues. For dogs with specific health concerns, the right treats—even at higher prices—may represent preventative health care rather than just indulgence.

Bulk Buying Advantages

Chewy.com offers multiple ways to maximize treat value through bulk purchasing. Many of these treats come in larger package sizes that reduce the per-ounce cost considerably. Bulk buying not only saves money but reduces packaging waste and ensures a consistent supply of your dog's preferred treats. Combining multiple items to reach free shipping thresholds adds another dimension of savings.

Subscription Savings

Auto-ship subscriptions on Chewy.com typically provide 5-10% discounts on recurring orders. For treats your dog consistently enjoys, this subscription model delivers both convenience and cost savings. The flexibility to adjust delivery schedules prevents oversupply issues while maintaining the discount benefits. These programs particularly benefit owners of larger dogs or multi-dog households who go through treats more quickly.

Balancing Quality and Budget

Finding the sweet spot between quality ingredients and budget constraints requires thoughtful evaluation. Some dogs with robust digestive systems may do perfectly well with more economical treats like Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy. Others with sensitive systems may actually save money in the long run with premium options like PureBites that prevent costly allergic reactions or digestive upsets. The most cost-effective approach often involves using higher-priced treats selectively while maintaining a variety of options at different price points.

Allergy Management with PureBites

Dogs with multiple food sensitivities find safe haven in PureBites' single-ingredient approach. With only freeze-dried beef liver in the formula, these treats eliminate exposure to common allergens like chicken, dairy, eggs, and grains. This simplicity makes them ideal for elimination diet protocols when identifying specific trigger ingredients. The absence of additives, preservatives, and fillers further reduces potential reaction sources. For severely allergic dogs, this minimalist approach provides treats that reward without risk.

Gluten Sensitivity and Merrick's Solution

Merrick Power Bites address gluten sensitivity through their grain-free formulation. By excluding wheat, barley, rye, and other gluten-containing grains, these treats provide safe options for dogs who react specifically to gluten proteins. The high meat content ensures palatability doesn't suffer despite the absence of grain-based binders. Some dogs show dramatic improvement in skin conditions, digestive function, and energy levels when gluten is removed from their diet, making these treats therapeutic as well as rewarding.

Supporting Specialized Diets with Stella & Chewy's

For dogs following raw, ancestral, or evolutionary diets, Stella & Chewy's Carnivore Crunch provides treat consistency with their primary feeding approach. The 98% meat, organ, and bone composition mirrors the nutritional profile these diets aim to achieve. This alignment prevents the digestive transitions that can occur when dogs switch between different food types. For owners committed to evolutionary feeding principles, these treats extend their nutritional philosophy to the reward component of their dog's diet.

Weight Management Considerations

Treat selection plays a crucial role in canine weight management. Charlee Bear's low-calorie profile (3 calories per treat) allows for frequent rewarding without significant caloric impact. For overweight dogs or those prone to weight gain, treating frequency often matters more than treating itself. Selecting lower-calorie options permits the behavioral benefits of rewards while supporting weight control goals. Breaking larger treats into smaller pieces can further extend the reward experience without adding calories.

Identifying Problematic Ingredients

Beyond specific dietary approaches, certain ingredients warrant scrutiny for all dogs. Artificial colors like Red 40 and Blue 2 provide no nutritional benefit and may trigger reactions in sensitive individuals. Chemical preservatives such as BHA, BHT, and ethoxyquin have raised health concerns, making natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) preferable. Generic meat "meals" or "by-products" without species identification may contain varying protein sources, which is problematic for dogs with specific meat sensitivities. Reading treat labels with these considerations in mind guides selection toward healthier options regardless of dietary approach.

After exploring these top 5 treats across grain-free, raw, and chewy categories, it's clear that Chewy.com offers options for every dog's dietary needs. The Merrick Power Bites and Charlee Bear crunchy treats stand out for grain-sensitive pups, while PureBites and Stella & Chewy's deliver pure nutrition for raw enthusiasts. For those needing softer options, Milk-Bone's chewy variety provides both palatability and enriched nutrition. Remember that the best treat is one that aligns with your dog's specific health requirements while still making their tail wag with excitement. I recommend starting with smaller packages to test preferences before committing to larger quantities. Your pup's gleeful reaction will be the ultimate review!